Skip to content

Mac Notification Sounds Too Loud in Headphones? Fix

You're wearing headphones, listening to music at a comfortable volume. A Slack notification fires. It's far louder than your music, and you pull your headphones off.

Download on the Mac App Store€14.99 one-time purchase · no subscription · macOS 14.2+ · Mac App Store

This happens because your Mac has one main volume slider for everything. Your music might sit at a comfortable level, but alert and notification sounds, from Slack pings to Calendar reminders and macOS system sounds, play under that same slider.

Why notifications sound louder than music

Notification sounds are short, sharp sounds designed to get your attention, so they hit hard at their peak by design. Music is mixed for sustained listening, with quieter and louder passages.

The system volume scales both by the same amount, but they start from very different places. So at a volume where your music is comfortable, a ping can still be startling. In headphones it feels worse: the sound goes straight into your ears, and a sharp ping stands out even more against quiet music.

There are two kinds of sound involved, and they need different fixes:

  • macOS alert sounds, such as the error beep or a sound effect, which follow the Sound settings below.
  • App notification sounds, such as Slack, Discord or Teams pings, which each app handles in its own way.

Fix 1: Send system alerts to your speakers

This is the headphone-specific fix most people miss. Open System Settings > Sound and look under Sound Effects for Play sound effects through. Apple describes it as the output device used to play sound effects. Pick your Mac's built-in speakers there, and macOS alerts no longer go into your ears while your music stays in the headphones.

It only covers system sound effects and alerts, not every app's pings, but it takes care of the beeps at once.

Fix 2: Lower the alert volume

In the same place, drag the Alert volume slider down. Apple notes that the alert volume is relative to your Mac's output volume, so when you lower the main volume, alerts get quieter too. Again, this is for macOS alerts; apps that play their own sounds may ignore it. If you also find the click on every volume change annoying, turn off Play feedback when volume is changed.

Fix 3: Turn off sounds for the loudest apps

Go to System Settings > Notifications, select the app that's too loud and turn off Play sound for notification. If the app's banners are on, they still appear, so you don't miss anything; you just don't hear it.

Many apps also have their own sound list. Discord, for example, lets you switch its notification sounds off in its own settings. Slack, Teams and messengers have similar options in their settings. App-specific guides: mute Slack without muting everything and WhatsApp and Telegram notifications.

Limitation: these switches are on or off. You can silence an app's pings, but not make them a bit quieter than your music.

Fix 4: Use a Focus while you listen

A Focus pauses and silences notifications, either all of them or all except the people and apps you allow. For a quick break, turn on Do Not Disturb in Control Center. To set up a custom Focus, go to System Settings > Focus and click Add Focus. Good for deep work, less practical if you need to notice messages all day.

Make one app quieter instead of silent

What most people actually want: Slack quieter, music unchanged. macOS doesn't offer that with its built-in controls.

SoundDial gives every app that plays sound its own volume slider and mute button in the menu bar, so you can lower an app that pings a lot while your music stays where it is. That's per-app volume control: one app lower, the others untouched.

Screen recording of SoundDial 2.0 with example settings. No sound. Spotify is raised from 35% to 160% (the slider turns amber above 100%), Discord is muted and Safari is lowered, while the other apps stay where they are.

A headphone-friendly setup

  • Spotify / Music: 50%, a comfortable listening level
  • Slack: 15%, noticeable but not startling
  • Zoom / FaceTime: 90%, clear call audio
  • Browser: 40%, close to your music for video

Or keep pings out of your ears entirely

Fix 1 moves macOS alerts to the speakers. SoundDial does the same for an app: open the app's ⋯ menu, choose Play Through and pick your Mac's speakers. That app now plays on the speakers while your music and calls stay in the headphones. See different output per app.

Test with your apps

If an app plays its notification sounds itself, they follow its SoundDial slider. Sounds that macOS plays on an app's behalf come from the system, and system processes get no slider in SoundDial; for those, use Fixes 1 to 3. Try a test message from the app you care about to see which case you have.

Save your headphone mix as a volume profile, and if everything gets too much at once, Control-Option-M mutes all apps in SoundDial's list from any app.

SoundDial works per app, not per browser tab, and doesn't read or record your microphone. More about SoundDial, a per-app volume mixer for Mac.

SoundDial is €14.99 one-time purchase on the Mac App Store, no subscription, and needs macOS 14.2 or later. Get SoundDial on the Mac App Store.

SoundDial: a volume slider and mute button for every app on your Mac.

€14.99 one-time purchase · macOS 14.2+ · no subscription