Set Mac Alert Volume Separate From Media Volume
Your music is at a nice level. Then a macOS alert fires and it's painfully loud next to your music. Or the opposite: your alerts are inaudible because the system volume is low for quiet background music.
What you want is two controls: one for media (music, calls, video) and one for alerts and notifications. macOS partly supports this. Here's what the built-in setting covers, what it misses, and how to close the gap.
The built-in alert volume
Open System Settings > Sound. Under Sound Effects, Apple lists these options (Apple Support):
- Alert sound: the sound that plays when you get an alert. A softer sound helps as much as a lower level.
- Play sound effects through: the output device for sound effects. Choose a different device than your music, for example the built-in speakers while music plays on headphones.
- Alert volume: the alert level.
- Play sound on startup: the startup chime.
- Play user interface sound effects: sounds for actions such as dragging an item to the Trash.
- Play feedback when volume is changed: a click when you change the volume.
The catch: alert volume is relative
Apple's own description: the alert volume is relative to the output volume of your Mac, so if you lower your Mac volume, alert sounds play more quietly too. The Alert volume can only take alerts down from the output volume, never above it. That explains both complaints at the start:
- Alerts too loud: lower Alert volume. Done for system alerts.
- Alerts too quiet: your output volume is low because you wanted quiet music. Lowering the main slider took the alerts down with it.
For the second case, flip the approach. Keep the output volume at a normal level and turn the music down instead, inside the music app. Apple notes that an app's own volume can only be equal to or lower than the computer's output volume, so the app gets quiet while alerts keep their level.
If you rely on alerts and still miss them, System Settings > Accessibility > Audio has Flash the screen when an alert sound occurs.
What the alert slider may not reach
The Alert volume slider is meant for macOS alerts and sound effects. Apps like Slack, Discord, Teams, Zoom and browsers often play their notification sounds in their own way, so the slider may not change them at all. The apps whose pings bother people most are often exactly the ones it can't reach.
Turn notification sounds down or off per app
For app notifications, macOS gives you an on/off switch per app. Go to System Settings > Notifications, select the app, and turn off Play sound for notification.
Many apps also have their own sound options. In Slack, Discord or Teams, look in the app's settings under notifications or sounds; some let you pick a quieter sound or turn sounds off.
The catch: these are mostly on or off. You can silence an app's pings, but not make them quieter than your music while still hearing them. And sounds that aren't notifications, such as a huddle or a video in a chat, keep playing at full level.
The real fix: a volume per app
To truly separate notification volume from media volume, you need a level per app: Slack quiet, Spotify comfortable, Zoom at full volume.
SoundDial, a per-app volume mixer for Mac, gives each app that plays sound its own slider in the menu bar, from 0% to 200%, plus a one-click mute. Set notification-heavy apps to a level that's noticeable but not jarring, and keep media apps where you like them. More: per-app volume control on Mac.
Example setup
Media apps:
- Spotify: 50%
- Safari or Chrome: 60%
- QuickTime or VLC: 70%
Notification apps:
- Slack: 15%
- Discord: 20%
- Telegram: 10%
Communication apps:
- Zoom or Teams: 100%
- FaceTime: 100%
This also solves the "alerts too quiet" case: leave the system volume up so alerts are clear, and drag Spotify down to background level in SoundDial instead.
Split by device, too
Just as Play sound effects through sends system alerts to another device, SoundDial's Play Through (in an app's ⋯ menu) sends one app to the output you choose: Slack on the speakers, music in the headphones. See different output per app.
Keep it set
With When an app opens set to Remember last in SoundDial's Settings > General, every app comes back at its level after a restart. Want a quiet evening mix and a work mix? Save each as a volume profile.
Where each control fits
Keep the macOS Alert volume slider for system sounds; system processes get no slider in SoundDial. Use per-app sliders for everything else, and test with a message from the app you care about. SoundDial works per app, not per browser tab, so all tabs of a browser share one slider.
For a broader guide, see controlling notification sounds on Mac.
SoundDial needs macOS 14.2 or later and is €14.99 one-time purchase on the Mac App Store, no subscription.
SoundDial: a volume slider and mute button for every app on your Mac.
€14.99 one-time purchase · macOS 14.2+ · no subscription